Common Penalty Types: How to Identify & Fix Them

Ever wondered why your content and SEO efforts just aren’t performing like they should? If you’re noticing a sudden drop in your website’s search rankings or organic traffic, you might be facing a Google penalty. 

Google penalties occur when your website violates one of Google’s Webmaster Guidelines, intentionally or accidentally, leading to reduced visibility on the search engine. This guide will help you diagnose the cause of the penalty and outline a plan to recover so you can regain your rankings and keep your site in good standing with Google.

Jump To 

Understanding Google Penalties

Your traffic has suddenly plummeted. Clicks are down, and your online sales have taken a steep dive. You’re following all the correct practices (or so you think), so why has your content’s performance dropped—or disappeared entirely? The culprit might be a Google penalty. Sometimes, despite your best efforts, Google’s algorithms or manual reviews catch something they see as a rule violation, leading to an unexpected hit for site owners who may not even realize they’ve crossed a line.

If you suspect a Google penalty might be behind your site’s sudden downturn, it’s essential to understand how and why these penalties are applied. 

Google enforces its guidelines through two main types of penalties: 

Algorithmic Penalties

Algorithmic penalties are automatically applied by Google’s algorithms when they detect certain quality or ranking guidelines violations. Unlike manual actions involving a person reviewing your site, algorithmic penalties are triggered solely by Google’s code. They are usually rolled out during algorithm updates like Panda, Penguin, or Core updates.

Manual Actions

Manual actions are penalties applied by a Google reviewer after examining your site. When Google’s team detects a violation, they apply a manual action, and you’ll receive a notification in Google Search Console. This notification will specify the issue, making it easier to identify the exact cause and take corrective action.

Diagnosing a Google Penalty

Check Google Search Console for Manual Actions

If a Google employee has applied a penalty, you’ll see a message describing the issue in the Manual Actions section. Common reasons for manual penalties include unnatural links, thin content, or user-generated spam, which we will expand on below.

Analyze Organic Traffic for Sudden Drops

Use Google Analytics to monitor your organic traffic closely for any unusual declines. Start by examining your traffic trends over time, focusing on organic traffic metrics. A sudden or significant drop in organic traffic can be a red flag indicating potential issues. To assess whether this decline might be due to an algorithmic penalty, compare the timing of the drop with recent Google algorithm updates.

Google regularly rolls out updates aimed at refining search quality, which often affect many sites across various industries. If your traffic decline coincides with a known algorithm update—such as one targeting content quality, user experience, or link-building practices—you may be dealing with an algorithmic penalty related to that specific update. You can also use tools like Google Search Console or third-party platforms that track Google’s algorithm changes to confirm if an update aligns with your traffic drop.

Audit Your Link Profile

Tools like Ahrefs, SEMrush, and Moz are invaluable for analyzing your backlink profile and identifying any low-quality or spammy links that might be causing problems. These platforms allow you to review your backlinks’ quality, relevance, and source, helping you pinpoint suspicious patterns or links from unreliable sites.

If you notice a sudden influx of links from unrelated, low-authority, or spammy domains, this could signal manipulative link-building practices that Google’s algorithms or manual reviewers often penalize.

Evaluate Content Quality and Structure

Thin content, duplicate pages, or poor user experience can all trigger penalties. Review your content for value, relevance, and originality to ensure it aligns with Google’s quality standards. Additionally, ensure a positive user experience by making your content easy to read and visually appealing. A well-structured site satisfies visitors and aligns with Google’s quality standards.

Common Types of Google Penalties and How to Fix Them

Unnatural Links

  • Diagnosis: If you see an “Unnatural links” message in Search Console, it likely means you have low-quality or spammy backlinks.
  • Recovery: Conduct a link audit to identify toxic backlinks. Use Google’s Disavow Tool to tell Google to ignore these links or reach out to the site owners to have the links removed.

Thin Content 

  • Diagnosis: Thin content penalties often arise from duplicate content or pages with very little value.
  • Recovery: Revamp low-quality pages by adding original, relevant content, or merge similar pages to create comprehensive resources. Remove or “noindex” duplicate content to avoid future penalties.

Keyword Stuffing

  • Diagnosis: Keyword stuffing involves using keywords excessively or unnaturally within content, which can lead to an algorithmic penalty.
  • Recovery: Rewrite the affected content with a focus on readability and user experience. Use keywords naturally and make sure the content is valuable and flows well. You can use Delta Growth’s Keyword Density Checker tool to make sure your content contains a good amount of relevant keywords without risking overstuffing. 

User-Generated Spam

  • Diagnosis: User-generated spam frequently arises on websites that allow open forums, comments, or guest posts. This type of spam can include irrelevant links, inappropriate content, or low-quality contributions, which can harm your site’s reputation and trigger penalties.
  • Recovery: Moderate and clean up spammy comments or guest posts, especially those with links. Implement captcha or moderation tools to prevent further spam.

Steps to Recover from a Google Penalty

Submit a Reconsideration Request

If your site received a manual penalty, you’ll need to submit a reconsideration request in Google Search Console. In your request, be transparent about the issues you’ve addressed and provide detailed information on the actions you’ve taken to rectify the problem. This demonstrates to Google that you are serious about compliance and willing to improve.

Focus on E-E-A-T 

Google prioritizes high-quality content that showcases Expertise, Authority, and Trustworthiness (E-E-A-T). Invest time in creating well-researched, informative, and engaging content that reflects your brand’s authority in its niche. This not only enhances your chances of ranking well but also builds credibility with your audience.

Build Quality Backlinks

Avoid using paid or manipulative link-building tactics. Instead, focus on earning links naturally by creating shareable content, engaging in guest blogging on reputable sites, and collaborating with industry influencers. Quality backlinks from trustworthy sources can significantly boost your site’s authority and visibility.

Regularly Monitor Your Site

Set up regular website audits to monitor your backlink profile, content quality, and overall user experience. Staying proactive with these audits can help you prevent future penalties and maintain your site’s health.

Stay Updated on Google Algorithm Changes

Google frequently updates its algorithms to improve the quality of search results. Follow reputable SEO blogs or subscribe to Google’s Search Central Blog to keep up with the latest changes and updates.

Answers to Common Questions About Diagnosing and Recovering From Google Penalties

How can I tell if my site has been penalized by Google?

To check for a penalty, start by looking at Google Search Console’s “Manual Actions” section for any messages from Google. Also, monitor your organic traffic in Google Analytics. A sudden, unexplained drop in traffic often signals an issue related to an algorithmic penalty.

What’s the difference between an algorithmic penalty and a manual penalty?

An algorithmic penalty is automatically applied by Google’s algorithms when they detect guideline violations, often around content quality or backlinks. Manual penalties are applied directly by Google’s review team and will appear as a message in Google Search Console, specifying the violation.

How long does it take to recover from a Google penalty?

Recovery times vary depending on the type of penalty and the issues that need fixing. Manual penalties may take a few weeks after a successful reconsideration request, while algorithmic penalties can take longer and often require significant adjustments to content, links, or user experience before rankings improve.

Can disavowing links help recover from a Google penalty?

Yes, if low-quality or spammy backlinks are causing the issue, disavowing them can help. Use the Google Disavow Tool in Search Console to tell Google to ignore these harmful links. Be careful only to disavow links that are genuinely spammy or harmful to your site’s reputation.

 How can I prevent Google penalties in the future?

Regularly audit your site’s content, backlinks, and technical SEO. Stay updated with Google’s Webmaster Guidelines and algorithm updates. Focus on providing high-quality, relevant content, and avoid any manipulative tactics like keyword stuffing or buying links.

How Delta Growth Can Help You Diagnose and Recover from SEO Penalties

Navigating the complexities of SEO and diagnosing penalties can be daunting, but you don’t have to face it alone. At Delta Growth, we specialize in identifying the root causes of your site’s performance issues and implementing effective recovery strategies tailored to your unique needs. Our team of experienced professionals understands the intricacies of Google’s algorithms and manual actions, allowing us to craft solutions that not only restore your search visibility but also enhance your overall online presence.

With a focus on quality content, authoritative backlinks, and an exceptional user experience, we empower you to thrive in a competitive digital landscape. Whether you’re dealing with a manual penalty or facing the repercussions of an algorithm update, Delta Growth is here to guide you every step of the way. Let us help you turn setbacks into opportunities for growth and success. 

Book a discovery call with the Delta Growth team today.